Judicial Ijtihad in Religious Courts in the Discovery of Law Concerning Women’s Rights after Divorce: An Analysis of Makassar Religious Court Decision No. 1516/Pdt.G/2026/PA.Mks
Main Article Content
Abstract
Religious Court judges do not always face complete and explicit norms, so legal discovery (rechtsvinding) and ijtihad matter in judicial reasoning, yet listing women’s post-divorce rights in a verdict does not by itself show that they result from ijtihad. This article analyzes Makassar Religious Court Decision Number 1516/Pdt.G/2026/PA.Mks, a divorce petition (cerai talak) in which partly successful mediation produced an agreement on child custody, child living costs, iddah maintenance, mut‘ah, madhiyah maintenance, and joint property. It aims to analyze the legal construction of these rights, the judge’s procedure for determining them, and the Islamic legal assessment of the judge’s legal discovery. This legal study of the written decision applies statutory provisions, the Compilation of Islamic Law, and scholarly literature, framed by ijtihad, maqāṣid al-syarī‘ah, al-maslahah, and the maxim al-ḍarar yuzāl. The rights are constructed through the relationship between marriage law provisions, the Compilation of Islamic Law, the principle of protecting women before the law, proven facts, and the parties’ agreement. The judge’s assessment of the ground for divorce, which qualifies proven facts as legal facts under Article 19 letter f of Government Regulation Number 9 of 1975 and Article 116 letter f of the Compilation, reveals legal reasoning, whereas nominal amounts of several rights stem from the mediation agreement and cannot automatically be categorized as rechtsvinding. Judicial ijtihad must be demonstrated in written legal considerations, and the quality of legal discovery lies in the coherence of legal basis, reasoning process, fairness of outcome, and real protection for rightholders.
Article Details
Issue
Section

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.